Reading Comprehension · UPSC Civil Services Examination 2026 · GS Paper II · Last updated:
Passage:
India is starting to deploy AI for critical use cases such as weather forecasting, pest detection and control, and crop yield optimisation. However, penetration is limited to a small subset of tech-savvy farmers. In the US and in Europe, generative AI tools have started offering precision farming at scale, integrating large datasets to provide real-time agronomic insights. For at-scale integration and accessibility of AI tools in India, it would be helpful to develop Indian languages-based AI tools for smallholder farmers, partner with AgTechs to create affordable AI solutions, and disseminate AI-based advisory services through government programmes.
Which of the following assumptions is/are valid?
- 1. Agricultural productivity has marched ahead in the West because of the economies of scale facilitated by the adoption of AI tools.
- 2. Affordable AI tools rendered available in local languages can help AI-based solutions reach more and more small farmers.
- 3. Though penetration is as yet low, critical application areas deploying AI tools are already in use in India.
Select the answer using the code given below.
- A. 1, 2 and 3
- B. 2 only
- C. 1 and 3 only
- D. 2 and 3 only (Correct answer)
Correct Answer
Option D — 2 and 3 only
Detailed Solution & Explanation
Key Points
- Valid assumptions are 2 and 3.
- 2 — the passage recommends affordable, local-language AI tools to reach smallholder farmers, assuming this will widen access.
- 3 — it states critical applications (weather, pest, yield) are already in use in India, though penetration is low.
Additional Information
- Assumption 1 is not valid — the passage credits Western progress to generative AI at scale and large datasets, not specifically to *economies of scale*; that is an over-reading. Hence 2 and 3 only → Option D.
- An assumption must be something the argument silently relies on. Statement 1 fails that test twice over: the passage never discusses *why* Western productivity rose, and it attributes the West's AI advantage to generative tools working over large datasets, not to economies of scale.
- Statement 3 is safely inferable from the opening line — India *is starting to deploy AI* for weather forecasting, pest detection and yield optimisation — combined with the admission that penetration is limited to a small subset of tech-savvy farmers. Both halves of the assumption are present.
- Statement 2 restates the passage's own prescription: Indian-language, affordable tools built with AgTechs and pushed through government programmes. A recommendation presupposes that it would work, so the assumption is valid.
- The reliable technique for CSAT assumption sets: keep any statement the passage needs in order to make sense, and reject any that adds a causal claim the author never made. Statement 1 is a causal claim, which is why the answer is 2 and 3 only.
Topics covered: Reading Comprehension