Indian Polity · JKCCE Prelims 2024 — General Studies Paper I · Last updated:

View the full solved paper: JKCCE Prelims 2024 — General Studies Paper I

Which of the following words are mentioned in 'Article 51-A (g)' of the Indian Constitution?

  • i. Rivers
  • ii. Forests
  • iii. Animals
  • iv. Lakes

Select the correct answer:

  1. A. i and ii only
  2. B. i, ii, and iii only
  3. C. i, ii, and iv only (Correct answer)
  4. D. i, iii, and iv only

Correct Answer

Option C — i, ii, and iv only

Detailed Solution & Explanation

Key Points

  • Article 51-A(g) reads: it shall be the duty of every citizen *"to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers and wild life, and to have compassion for living creatures"*.
  • The words actually used are therefore rivers (i), forests (ii) and lakes (iv).
  • "Animals" (iii) does not appear. The clause says "wild life", and speaks separately of compassion for "living creatures". This precise wording is the whole point of the question.

Additional Information

  • Fundamental Duties were added by the 42nd Amendment Act, 1976, on the recommendation of the Swaran Singh Committee, and are contained in Part IV-A, Article 51-A. Ten duties were added; the 86th Amendment Act, 2002 added the eleventh — the duty of a parent or guardian to provide education to a child between six and fourteen years.
  • The Fundamental Duties were borrowed from the Constitution of the USSR. India, Japan and a few other countries list citizens' duties; the American Constitution has no such list.
  • They apply only to citizens, not to foreigners, and are non-justiciable — no court can enforce them directly. Parliament may, however, provide for their enforcement by suitable legislation, and the courts read them in when interpreting statutes and testing the reasonableness of restrictions.
  • The other environment-related provisions:
    • Article 48-A (Directive Principle, also inserted by the 42nd Amendment) — the State shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and safeguard forests and wild life. Article 51-A(g) places the parallel obligation on the citizen.
    • Article 21 has been read by the Supreme Court to include the right to a clean and healthy environment, in cases from *Subhash Kumar* to *M.C. Mehta*.
  • The Verma Committee (1999) on the operationalisation of Fundamental Duties identified the legal provisions that already exist to enforce several of them.

Exam Tip

  • For Article 51-A(g), remember the exact quartet — forests, lakes, rivers and wild life — plus compassion for living creatures. Questions on this clause are almost always about which of those words is or is not present.

Topics covered: Indian Polity